Case Studies

The following case summaries highlight common issues and consumer tips. Cases can be filtered by subject below and names have been changed to protect confidentiality. Access to the full case study database is available for IFSO Scheme Participants in the Participant Area.

No cover for missing ruby

Check your policy exclusions. Check your jewellery for wear and tear.

Sophia’s claim, for the missing ruby in her wedding ring, was declined due to wear and tear over 42 years.
House and Contents Insurance

See the case summary

No cover for derelict house after fire

Your insurer can decline your claim if it can prove you didn’t take “reasonable care”.

Before Liam’s house was set on fire, it wasn’t in good shape due to vandalism and neglect.
House and Contents Insurance Fire

See the case summary

Pay out for stolen ring disappointing

Specify items of value on your policy. Check the sum insured.

Wiremu was disappointed to be receive an insurance payout that was less than it cost to replace his stolen ring.
House and Contents Insurance Sum Insured

See the case summary

Investments can go up and down

Your investment value is affected by the changing value of the assets you invest in.

Finlay complained because his investment had reduced in value. But the rate of returns were not guaranteed.
Superannuation & Investments

See the case summary

Investment loss from KiwiSaver mistake

If a mistake is made by your provider, you may receive payment for your financial loss.

Ricky wanted $120,000 compensation as his KiwiSaver provider hadn't transferred his funds for two months. He got $300.
Superannuation & Investments KiwiSaver

See the case summary

Less than expect from your Superannuation

If you withdraw your superannuation early, you might not get the full value.

Ashani withdrew her Superannuation funds and received $2,000 less than the full value of her plan.
Superannuation & Investments

See the case summary

KiwiSaver early withdrawal rules super strict

The early withdrawal criteria for KiwiSaver is strict. In some circumstances, Kiwisaver may not be right for you

Eugene was unlikely to live until age 65. Despite this, he could not access his KiwiSaver savings.
Superannuation & Investments KiwiSaver

See the case summary

Earthquake: repair v replace

Providing expert evidence is important to dispute an insurer’s decision

An insurer deemed an earthquake-damaged property repairable but the owner disagreed and wanted it replaced.
Natural Disasters

See the case summary

No access, no business

Check your policy for the definition of loss. Insurance covers damaged property.

Christine’s clothing store was yellow-stickered, which affected her business. But her property wasn’t damaged.
Natural Disasters

See the case summary

Cover for motel, not for carparks

Business interruption cover applies to specific circumstances. Check your policy.

Jim’s claim for his earthquake-damaged motel was accepted, but his claim for loss of income from carparks was declined.
Natural Disasters

See the case summary

No temporary accommodation cover

Temporary accommodation cover may apply. Check your policy.

Charlie’s rental house was damaged during the Christchurch earthquake. When he moved back in he wasn’t eligible for cover.
Natural Disasters landlord temporary accommodation

See the case summary